Cultural Endowment of Estonia in architecture / annual award 2021 nominee
Author
Siim Tuksam
Supervisors
dr Renee Puusepp (Estonian Academy of Arts) and dr Antoine Picon (Harvard University)
Defended
on 22 December 2020 at the Estonian Academy of Arts
Photos
Margus Tammik, Tõnu Tunnel

  108

Siim Tuksam’s doctoral thesis deals with some of the most burning topics in contemporary construction and architecture, “How to make construction more effective and sustainable?” and “How to create architecturally high-quality living environments?” In close cooperation with timber house manufacturers, the theoretical concepts and digital solutions were tested in physical prototypes and larger projects. As the thesis deals with the promotion of timber architecture, it can potentially have a direct influence on the improvement of social welfare and living environments. Timber construction in urban spaces is gradually gaining ground. In order to ensure environmental-friendly urban development, it is vital to invest in timber construction. The given thesis suggests an original solution based on manufacturing but relying on architecture.
Renee Puusepp, PhD Senior Researcher at the Estonian Academy of Arts

The milestone projects, from left to right: the Body Building installation, Urban Jungle vertical garden and Shift Lofts timber apartment building. © PART.

The digitalisation of the construction industry is in full swing. The infrastructure for the computer-aided manufacturing of buildings is here, yet mass customisation by robotically manufactured infinitesimally variable components, as suggested by the early digital architects of the 1990s, is still not viable on an industrial scale. Architecture seems to be forced to adapt to the industry rather than the other way round. How is it possible, within this context, to maintain the autonomy of the architectural discipline, facing the realities of extensive standardisation, automation, and artificial intelligence?

Digital architecture as a critical discourse was largely built upon Gilles Deleuze’s idea of folding, proposing a continuous formation of matter based on intensities. Folding in architecture resulted in an almost frictionless combination of topology and tectonics, where the whole consists of continuously variegated adaptive details. It is this continuous adaptation that is contested within the thesis in which modulation is proposed as an active intervention rather than frictionless optimisation – subverting the prevailing ideology from within by taking the system more seriously than the system takes itself, to paraphrase Slavoj Žižek.

In terms of the historic perspective, the thesis looks at the development of modularity in architecture, starting with Jean-Nicolas-Louis Durand and his analytical method as well as the mid-twentieth century modular structures inspired by system theory, forming the lineage towards the digitisation of architecture. The introduction of modularity into digital architecture produces an internal tension that constrains the formation of matter. German architect Eckhard Schulze-Fielitz explored this type of emergent formation through the term Raumstruktur (structure of space), a macro material capable of modulation. By modulating the conditioning circumstances into a model of the Raumstruktur, a design space is created that governs formation – not a mould, but an emergent structure of space.

These internal tensions manifest themselves in the formal qualities of this macro material as an expression of the underlying structure. Through this expression, the communicative and political dimensions of modulation are explored in the thesis, suggesting an ornamental quality within the work and therefore a differentiation from mere construction.

The study is both projective and reflective – experimental research by design that turns into both practice research and theoretical research. Through a series of projects in collaboration with the Estonian wooden house manufacturing industry, this exploration has evolved from looking at mimetic algorithms and variable tectonics towards a pre-rationalised design approach – modulated modularity.

Siim Tuksam

Moulding vs. Modulation – crumpling polygons instead of paper. Diagram by the author.